| |
I hope I find you in good health. There has been some heated debate in
the press recently on whether HIV can be spread through kissing. Beatrice Tonhodzayi
started the fire in her "Lets Talk About Aids" column ( I think she
is doing a terrific job). I got a flood of e-mails wanting me to confirm, clarify
or explain whether this was true or not. So heated has been the debate that the
only way to cool it is to let it burn and I'm going to do just that. HIV has
been found in saliva and tears in very low quantities from some AIDS patients.
It is important to understand that finding a small amount of HIV in a body fluid
does not necessarily mean that HIV can be transmitted by that body fluid. Contact
with saliva or tears, has not been shown to result in transmission of HIV. Kissing
someone on the cheek, also known as social kissing, does not pose any risk of
HIV transmission. However deep or open mouthed or so called "French"
kissing is considered a very low risk activity for transmission of HIV. This is
because HIV is present in saliva but only in very minute quantities, insufficient
to lead to HIV infection alone. You need a certain minimum concentration of the
virus to be able to infect someone. In theory, kissing in which saliva is
exchanged can transmit HIV infection, but in reality, there are no proven cases.
Several possible cases have arisen, but were subsequently disproved. There has
been a single documented case so far of probable transmission of HIV through kissing.
In July 1997 the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) researchers, investigated a
case of HIV transmission from an HIV-infected man to his female partner. The couple
reported using condoms consistently and correctly during the probable period of
viral transmission. After eliminating all other possible risk factors, the investigators
concluded that the woman most likely became infected through mucous membrane exposure
to her partner's saliva that was contaminated by blood from bleeding gums.
But
as it turns out, even the CDC can't really be sure the HIV was transmitted from
the man to the woman through kissing. Although the couple claimed they always
used a condom and never had anal sex, the claims are unverified. They also claim
their oral sex activity did not involve transmission of semen or blood. (I guess
we all know how effective the withdrawal method of birth control is?) And the
woman denied having sex with others. (How many women or men would admit to cheating?).
So there are a lot of holes in this claim. Saliva contains such low concentrations
of the virus, that infection via saliva is unlikely. There is a great deal of
evidence to support this fact. In a study of 79 men with AIDS, the virus could
be found in the saliva of only one. This man had pneumocystis pneumonia (PCP),
oral thrush, and other mouth and throat lesions. Even in this man, the level of
virus found in his saliva was 10,000 times less than the level in his blood. To
this study we can add the evidence of the countless numbers of people who have
had saliva contact with people with AIDS or others who have been infected. This
contact has occurred through kissing, sharing food, sharing cigarettes, and many
other means. There was no evidence that these activities have transmitted the
virus even a single time. Recent findings suggest that saliva contains some germ-killing
enzyme which seem effective against HIV. Certainly there is a lot at work in the
mouth combining to make the mouth an hostile environment for the virus. They are
acids, enzymes, friction, dilution, air, and more. Another factor that must
be considered, however, is blood in the mouth. If a person is infected, his or
her blood contains a high concentration of the virus and blood is far more infectious
than saliva alone. The presence of blood in the mouth is a common event and sometimes
its not obvious. Blood in the mouth may originate from bites, abrasions, flossing,
oral sores and bleeding gums. Kissing, if done roughly, can also create bleeding
points in the mucous membranes of the gums and cheeks. When both partners have
cuts or sores then there is a possibility of blood (not saliva) transmission of
HIV in the mouth. If you or your partner have blood in the mouth, you should avoid
kissing until the bleeding stops. However, many infected individuals at high-risk
for infection are being told that kissing is totally safe. This advice may not
be wise. The risk of catching HIV infection from wet kissing is close to zero,
but it is not zero so you still need to proceed with caution
Till next
week take care of yourself and each other. And remember, '
in all your getting,
get understanding.' (Proverbs 4 verse 7).
Dr
P. Chimedza is a medical practitioner with a special interest in HIV and AIDS.
Information for this article was researched from different medical textbooks,
medical journals and other medical information sources for which this author hereby
acknowledges. This column is kindly sponsored by Generation Health. For further
information on this topic and suggestions on future topics for discussion you
can mail him on pchimedza@hotmail.com.
|